Pitch Invasion is reporting that MLS is "seriously considering" changing the MLS playoff structure, but it actually looks more like what we just saw from the World Football Challenge with home-field advantage added than any sort of nod to the WPS.
I still don't like it, but that's not because I'm any sort of single-table purist. It's simply too many matches, and historically, selling tickets to playoff games has been inexplicably difficult for MLS clubs. This experiment with two-game aggregate series is the worst of both worlds, in that it kowtows to the Europhile and the Champions League format, despite the fact that the underlying reasons for a two-leg series don't exist.
However, if the Board of Governors is actually considering this idea, it means that the idea that every team in the playoffs has to have at least one home match seems to no longer be a prerequisite. This should, hopefully, open the door to the most sane approach that hasn't been tried, and that's a regular old single-game knockout format. The regular season would still have meaning, because in a single match, home field is going to be pretty important. Fewer games mean fewer potential conflicts for scheduling both stadiums and broadcast coverage.
If the purists complain that playoffs are such an American concept, why not offer them up in the style of American football?
I'm with you.
Seems to me that we already have a group stage. It's called the regular season. It's longer and better at weeding out the teams that don't belong than a one-week quickie group stage that could easily lead to meaningless playoff games (if a team wins its first two). And you mention the time element. Three playoff games to sell at short notice and play over a short length of time is a task not many MLS ticket sales teams would relish.
Hell Has Just Frozen Over
posted to
April 3, 2011
Opening Day Jitters
posted to
March 20, 2011
Bob Bradley's Five Favorite Words
posted to
March 7, 2011
A Big If, MLS Edition
posted to
February 28, 2011